
Original version recorded October 1962
Roger And Dave version recorded September 11, 2009
Andy Breslau – Vocals Drums, and Harmonica
Roger Greenawalt – Ukulele, Bass, and Percussion
Produced by Roger Greenawalt at Shabby Road Studio, Brooklyn.
For best results play Love Me Do on repeat while reading this essay.
ABOUT THE SONG
It is said that all great fortunes begin with a crime.
So too The Beatles.
No, the crime wasn’t John Lennon selling his soul to Satan backstage at The Star Club in Hamburg in 1960 in exchange for his subsequent massive material success. There is no law against selling your soul.
Nor was the crime the horrific human sacrifice of Lennon’s best friend Stu Sutcliffe that Satan additionally demanded from him. That murder is alleged, not proven. John was never even charged.
No, the crime that The Beatles enormous pile of money rests so opulently upon is far more prosaic:
Shoplifting.
The Beatles, like most fads, had a gimmick from the get go.

Their gimmick was harmonica.
A Hohner harmonica.
A harmonica that had been shoplifted by John Lennon, and that he played.
The very first sound on the very first Beatles single, Love Me Do, is that very same stolen harmonica. The Beatles early singles are riddled with harmonica, so much so that they actually rebelled against it, in the first of many rebellions. The poor harmonica was banished by 1964, never to be used again on any another Beatles song.
You can only play a harmonica in certain keys. It has no “black” notes. This particular harmonica of Lennon’s was in the key of C. A C harmonica works on a G blues. Love Me Do is a G blues. It also works on C major. The Beatles third single, From Me to You, which also features the same pilfered harmonica, is in the key of C major. This is how they picked their keys back then, not by what key was good for the vocalist. Hence another problem with Love Me Do, it’s too low for McCartney’s voice, especially in the B section, the part he didn’t write. Paul can barely get down to the “Someone to love” lines. He strains.
The signature instrument that The Beatles really turned the world on to was the electric guitar.
An instrument that Love Me Do lacks completely.
Instead of electric guitar there is acoustic guitar, which like the harmonica, is a folk or country instrument. The song sounds like it could have been played and recorded on a back porch. It resembles a discarded Everly Brothers B-Side. Even the title has whack grammar, it sounds like it was translated literally from the German. You would never in real life say “Love Me Do”. The phrase Love Me Do’s only redeeming quality is in providing a rhyme for “You” and “True”.
Love Me Do sounds like an inexperienced 16-year old kid fiddling around in his bedroom while skipping school wrote it.
It was.
That boy was Paul McCartney.
The middle eight, or B section, was written by John Lennon. It’s fascinating, that even at this fetal stage of their development, the dichotomous tensions between John and Paul’s writing and worldview were already in evidence.
Paul writes the chirpy and charming hook, all wide-eyed innocence, even romantically promising to never cheat.
Lennon responds with “Someone to love” (that could be anybody). “Somebody New”
(Let’s not mention the secret wife back in Liverpool). “Someone like you” (You’ll do for now). Lennon captures the predatory realities of male adolescents and baby rock stars precisely in these few otherwise banal lines. John’s been to Hamburg. He’d grown accustomed to immediate sexual abundance.
There is a Spinal Tappian aspect to Love Me Do, as there is to life in general. Love Me Do is the graveyard of Beatle drummers. Pete Best, Ringo Starr, and Alan White, all recorded versions of the track. It was Ringo’s version that appears on the single, and Alan White’s on the first album. Pete Best’s version only saw the light of day in 1995, on the Anthology 1 CD.
God it must suck to be Pete Best. To be that close and yet so far…
John and Paul had long wanted to get rid of Pete for the same reason Stu had to go. He was significantly better looking than either of them. Yes darlings, Pete Best was a seriously beautiful young man.

Oscar Wilde would have written him a poem.
“Peter my spirit, so weak is their shame,
Denying our Eden,
The love that dare not speak its name.”
Pete’s fate, already imperiled, was sealed when Producer/Label Head George Martin hated his drumming. Martin really didn’t like Love Me Do. What he liked was the fucking harmonica.
He later said:
"I loved wailing harmonica — it reminded me of the records I used to issue of Sonny Terry and Brownie McGhee.”
George reluctantly picked Love Me Do to be The Beatles debut single. For the same reason most choices are made.
It was the best that they had at the time.
The Roger And Dave version of Love Me Do features the incendiary harmonica and scary horror movie villain voice of Andy Breslau. Our goal was to restore the original Lennonesque menace of male desire. Do let us know how we did.
Do.
ABOUT THE ARTIST
The relevant facts: Andy Breslau was in Mrs. Korstad’s kindergarten class at Radnor Elementary School in Bethesda, Maryland with Roger. He sometime later impersonated Malcolm McLaren in order to secure Roger’s band the Dark a gig opening up for Bow Wow Wow. Presently, Andy runs a not for profit that tries to spur government to think more creatively about a range of public policy issues that perhaps can best be described as a noble but doomed enterprise. When he has had the time over the years, he has produced some records, played on some others, written liner notes for a few more, and staged some concerts. Somehow cobbling together a Zelig like musical life, Andy has been lucky enough to work with (in one fashion or another): The Holmes Brothers, Luther Johnson, Little Buster, Catherine Russell, Steve Riley and the Mamou Playboys, Nathan and the Zyedco Cha Chas, Kathy Mattea, Kath Bloom, Aimee Mann, Van Morrison and a bunch more folks like Joan Osborne and Karl Wallinger.






















